--- title: The Complex Relationship Between Crowdsourcing and Innovation description: There are challenges that come with seeking innovation through crowdsourcing, but there are benefits to crowdsourcing, and there are a number of success stories to learn from and ideas to mitigate any issues that arise. image: https://blog.flexmr.net/hubfs/The%20Complex%20Relationship%20Between%20Crowdsourcing%20and%20Innovation.png --- close ## Ready to level up your insights? Get ready to streamline, scale and supercharge your research. Fill out this form to request a demo of the InsightHub platform and discover the difference insights empowerment can make. A member of our team will reach out within two working days. close ## Cost effective insights that scale Quality insight doesn't need to cost the earth. Our flexible approach helps you make the most of research budgets and build an agile solution that works for you. Fill out this form to request a call back from our team to explore our pricing options. [![FlexMR logo](https://www.flexmr.net/skin/images/images-custom/2b221b67-b091-4584-9017-872ee2ddf960-logo.svg)](https://www.flexmr.net/) Book a Demo Request Pricing [Contact Us](https://www.flexmr.net/contact/) Menu - [Home](https://www.flexmr.net/) - [InsightHub](https://www.flexmr.net/insighthub/) - [What is InsightHub?](https://www.flexmr.net/insighthub/) - [Data Collection](https://www.flexmr.net/insighthub/data-collection/) - [Data Analysis](https://www.flexmr.net/insighthub/data-analysis/) - [Data Activation](https://www.flexmr.net/insighthub/data-activation/) - [Research Templates](https://blog.flexmr.net/topic/survey-templates/) - [Information Security](https://www.flexmr.net/insighthub/information-security/) - [Services](https://www.flexmr.net/services/) - [Our Expert Services](https://www.flexmr.net/services/) - [Support & Education](https://www.flexmr.net/services/support-and-education/) - [Consultative Services](https://www.flexmr.net/services/consultative-services/) - [Insight Delivery](https://www.flexmr.net/services/insight-delivery-services/) - [Research Methods](https://www.flexmr.net/methods/) - [Sectors We Work With](https://www.flexmr.net/sectors/) - [About](https://www.flexmr.net/about/) - [About Us](https://www.flexmr.net/about/) - [Leadership](https://www.flexmr.net/about/leadership/) - [Meet the team](https://www.flexmr.net/about/meet-the-team/) - [Advisory Board](https://www.flexmr.net/about/advisory-board/) - [Press & Media](https://resources.flexmr.net/tag/press) - [Accolades](https://www.flexmr.net/about/accolades/) - [Careers](https://www.flexmr.net/about/careers/) - [Blog](https://blog.flexmr.net/) - [Resources](https://resources.flexmr.net) - [Contact](https://www.flexmr.net/contact/) - [Book a Demo](https://blog.flexmr.net/) - [Request Pricing](https://blog.flexmr.net/) - [Home](https://www.flexmr.net/) - [InsightHub](https://www.flexmr.net/insighthub/) - - [What is InsightHub?](https://www.flexmr.net/insighthub/) - [Data Collection](https://www.flexmr.net/insighthub/data-collection/) - [Data Analysis](https://www.flexmr.net/insighthub/data-analysis/) - [Data Activation](https://www.flexmr.net/insighthub/data-activation/) - [Research Templates](https://blog.flexmr.net/topic/survey-templates/) - [Information Security](https://www.flexmr.net/insighthub/information-security/) - ![Camp InsightHub](https://blog.flexmr.net/hubfs/Website_Files/Images/Navigation/camp_insighthub_nav.png) Embark on a new adventure. Join Camp InsightHub, our free demo platform, to discover the future of research. [Sign Up Today](https://insighthub.flexmr.net/users/new) - ![FlexMR InsightHub](https://blog.flexmr.net/hubfs/Website_Files/Images/Navigation/insighthub_screenshot.png) Read a brief overview of the agile research platform enabling brands to inform decisions at speed in this PDF. [Download Brochure](https://blog.flexmr.net/hubfs/Public_Files/InsightHub_Brochure.pdf) - ### InsightHub on the Blog - [Surveys, Video and the Changing Face of Agile Research](https://blog.flexmr.net/surveys-video-changing-agile-research) - [Building a Research Technology Stack for Better Insights](https://blog.flexmr.net/research-technology-stack) - [The Importance of Delegation in Managing Insight Activities](https://blog.flexmr.net/delegation-importance-insight-activities) - [Common Insight Platform Pitfalls (and How to Avoid Them)](https://blog.flexmr.net/platform-pitfalls-how-to-avoid-them) - [Services](https://www.flexmr.net/services/) - - [Our Expert Services](https://www.flexmr.net/services/) - [Support and Education](https://www.flexmr.net/services/support-and-education/) - [Consultative Services](https://www.flexmr.net/services/consultative-services/) - [Insight Delivery Services](https://www.flexmr.net/services/insight-delivery-services/) - [Research Methods](https://www.flexmr.net/methods/) - [Sectors We Work With](https://www.flexmr.net/sectors/) - ![FlexMR Services Team](https://blog.flexmr.net/hubfs/Website_Files/Images/Navigation/services.jpg) Our services drive operational and strategic success in challenging environments. Find out how. [Download Brochure](https://blog.flexmr.net/hubfs/Public_Files/Brochures/FlexMR_Services_Brochure.pdf) - ![Video Close Connection Programme](https://blog.flexmr.net/hubfs/Website_Files/Images/Navigation/video_services.jpg) Close Connections bring stakeholders and customers together for candid, human conversations. [Read Press Release](https://resources.flexmr.net/close-connections-launch) - ### Explore our Practices - [Communities Practice](https://www.flexmr.net/insighthub/) - [Closeness Practice](https://www.flexmr.net/practices/customer-closeness/) - [CX Practice](https://www.flexmr.net/practices/customer-experience/) - [Insight Communications Practice](https://www.flexmr.net/practices/insight-communications/) - [About](https://www.flexmr.net/about/) - - [About Us](https://www.flexmr.net/about/) - [Leadership](https://www.flexmr.net/about/leadership/) - [Meet the Team](https://www.flexmr.net/about/meet-the-team/) - [Advisory Board](https://www.flexmr.net/about/advisory-board/) - [Press & Media](https://resources.flexmr.net/tag/press) - [Accolades](https://www.flexmr.net/about/accolades/) - [Careers](https://www.flexmr.net/about/careers/) - ![FlexMR Credentials Deck](https://blog.flexmr.net/hubfs/Website_Files/Images/Navigation/flexmr_credentials.png) The FlexMR credentials deck provides a brief introduction to the team, our approach to research and previous work. [Download Credentials](https://blog.flexmr.net/hubfs/Public_Files/Brochures/FlexMR_Credentials.pdf) - ![FlexMR Insights Empowerment](https://blog.flexmr.net/hubfs/Website_Files/Images/Navigation/insights_empowerment.png) We are the insights empowerment company. Our framework addresses the major pressures insight teams face. [Download Brochure](https://blog.flexmr.net/hubfs/Public_Files/Brochures/Insights_Empowerment_Brochure.pdf) - ### Latest News - [Insight as Art Shortlisted for AURA Innovation Award](https://resources.flexmr.net/aura-innovation-award-2021) - [FlexMR Launch Video Close Connection Programme](https://resources.flexmr.net/close-connections-launch) - [VideoMR Analysis Tool Added to InsightHub](https://resources.flexmr.net/videomr-launch) - [FlexMR Makes Shortlist for Quirks Research Supplier Award](https://resources.flexmr.net/quirksmr-mr-supplier-award-2020) - [Blog](https://blog.flexmr.net) - - [Latest Posts](https://blog.flexmr.net) - [Strategic Thinking](https://blog.flexmr.net/topic/strategic-thinking) - [Technology & Trends](https://blog.flexmr.net/topic/tech-trends) - [Research Methods](https://blog.flexmr.net/topic/research-methods) - [Practical Application](https://blog.flexmr.net/topic/practical-application) - [Insights Empowerment](https://blog.flexmr.net/topic/insights-empowerment) - [View Full Blog Archives](https://blog.flexmr.net/all) - ![FlexMR Close Connection Programme](https://blog.flexmr.net/hubfs/Website_Files/Images/Navigation/close_connection.png) Discover how to build close customer connections to better support real-time decision making. [Build Connections](https://blog.flexmr.net/practical-support-real-time-decisions) - ![Market Research Playbook](https://blog.flexmr.net/hubfs/Website_Files/Images/Navigation/market_research_playbook.png) What is a market research and insights playbook, plus discover why should your team consider building one. [Discover Playbooks](https://blog.flexmr.net/market-research-playbook) - ### Featured Posts - [Five Strategies for Turning Insight into Action](https://blog.flexmr.net/5-strategies-turn-insights-into-action) - [How to Design Surveys that Ask the Right Questions](https://blog.flexmr.net/effective-survey-design-guide) - [Scaling Creative Qual for Rich Customer Insight](https://blog.flexmr.net/scale-creative-qual-rich-understanding) - [How to Measure Brand Awareness: The Complete Guide](https://blog.flexmr.net/measure-brand-awareness) - [Resources](https://resources.flexmr.net) - - [All Resources](https://resources.flexmr.net) - [Client Stories](https://resources.flexmr.net/tag/case-studies) - [Whitepapers](https://resources.flexmr.net/tag/whitepapers) - [Events & Webinars](https://resources.flexmr.net/tag/events) - [The Open Ideas Panel](https://ideas.flexmr.net/auth/sign_in) - [InsightHub Help Centre](https://help.flexmr.net/en) - [FlexMR Client Network](https://www.linkedin.com/groups/9165407/) - ![Insights Empowerment Readiness Calculator](https://blog.flexmr.net/hubfs/Website_Files/Images/Navigation/insights_calculator.png) The insights empowerment readiness calculator measures your progress in building an insight-led culture. [Get Your Score](https://resources.flexmr.net/insights-empowerment-calculator) - ![MRX Lab Podcast](https://blog.flexmr.net/hubfs/Website_Files/Images/Navigation/flexmr_podcast.png) The MRX Lab podcast explores new and novel ideas from the insights industry in 10 minutes or less. [Listen Now](https://resources.flexmr.net/mrx-lab-podcast) - ### Featured Stories - [Specsavers Informs Key Marketing Decisions with InsightHub](https://resources.flexmr.net/specsavers) - [The Coventry Panel Helps Maintain Award Winning CX](https://resources.flexmr.net/coventry-building-society) - [Isagenix Customer Community Steers New Product Launch](https://resources.flexmr.net/isa-insights) - [Curo Engage Residents with InsightHub Community](https://resources.flexmr.net/curo) - [Tech & Trends](https://blog.flexmr.net/topic/tech-trends) / - [Research Methods](https://blog.flexmr.net/topic/research-methods) / - [Practical Application](https://blog.flexmr.net/topic/practical-application) / 9 MIN READ ## The Complex Relationship Between Crowdsourcing and Innovation #### Emily James # [Workshops and Beacons: A Guide to Building Custome...](https://blog.flexmr.net/workshops-beacons-customer-salience) Most organisations are not short of data, insight or decks.Their biggest challenge is not whether cu... [Read more](https://blog.flexmr.net/workshops-beacons-customer-salience) 9 MIN READ #### Ed Hill - [Events (1)](https://blog.flexmr.net/topic/events) - [Insights Empowerment (38)](https://blog.flexmr.net/topic/insights-empowerment) - [Practical Application (178)](https://blog.flexmr.net/topic/practical-application) - [Research Methods (285)](https://blog.flexmr.net/topic/research-methods) - [Strategic Thinking (232)](https://blog.flexmr.net/topic/strategic-thinking) - [Survey Templates (7)](https://blog.flexmr.net/topic/survey-templates) - [Tech & Trends (397)](https://blog.flexmr.net/topic/tech-trends) Innovation and Crowdsourcing are complex topics by nature, each with their own set of unique challenges; for insight professionals, this means working out how to carefully navigate both topics when they arise. Taking them on their own isn’t too much of an issue, but if we are looking to use crowdsourcing as a way of ideating and developing an innovation, then that’s when things start to get a bit tricky. There are articles relaying both the positive and negative effects of crowdsourcing on the pursuit of innovation, exploring success stories and tales of woe, all with their own merits and points that we should take into account when using the crowdsourcing method to strive for innovative insights. My aim in this blog is to bring some of that information together to explore why crowdsourcing and innovation have such a complex relationship and see what we can do to mitigate any issues that may occur. | ![Tweet from FlexMR](https://www.flexmr.net/images/webpage-images/45-tweet-this-from-flexmr.png) | ***Tweet This*** | | --- | --- | | [Innovation and crowdsourcing are complex topics by nature with their own unique challenges. When they collide in a research project, navigating these challenges will be tough.](https://ctt.ac/281bK) | | ### The Trouble with Crowdsourcing and Innovation First of all, crowdsourcing is a method that [outsources a task](https://symbiosisonlinepublishing.com/computer-science-technology/computerscience-information-technology01.php) generally assigned to a professional to a large group of customers and consumers in the form of an open call. So they participate in research that identifies innovation and brings it to life. There have been many positive impacts on crowdsourcing on innovation such as greater opportunity identification and attainment, but opportunity isn’t always realised to the best of its potential. There are also a few drawbacks that make us really think about whether this method is worth the insights it produces. Here are some of the issues that have been identified with crowdsourcing: 1. What happens in regards to intellectual property? Who owns what if you’re putting ideas out into the air for all to see and comment on and improve? 2. What about the data security and protection of the participants and the company? With nothing confidential, how can you promise that the safety of their personal data? 3. Participants are more prone to derailment and tangents when chatting together, thus we sometimes don’t actually get any answers at all because they’ve gone off on a different topic. 4. They don’t know how to contribute properly, thus allowing poor quality data to filter through the cracks and flood the datasets generated. 5. They are not experts in your field, they do not know the precision required to keep the business afloat, nor the context in which your business is thriving, they can lead you in the wrong direction at whim and they won’t even realise they’re doing it. An even worse scenario would be that they think they know all about the landscape you’re operating in, and actively if still unintentionally derail your entire operation with their opinions. These ethical and operational issues mean that navigating crowdsourced research in the name of innovation is tricky, and most of the insights generated are [essentially useless](https://hbr.org/2019/12/why-crowdsourcing-often-leads-to-bad-ideas). But this doesn’t mean that crowdsourcing is useless in innovative efforts, in fact, there are some crucial success stories that help us understand how to navigate this minefield, like [Apple](https://hbr.org/2013/04/using-the-crowd-as-an-innovation-partner) and their app creation techniques, Lego’s fantastically successful [Ideas Platform](https://www.planbox.com/4-companies-that-are-killing-it-with-crowdsourcing/), and Dell’s [IdeaStorm](https://www.informationweek.com/10-crowdsourcing-success-stories/d/d-id/1096464?page_number=2) site that allows customers a direct link to the technology company for developmental suggestions. And with examples like these fuelling the fire, we need to talk about how we manage the research process to mitigate the risk posed by crowdsourcing to both participants and organisations? ### Mitigating the Risk The first issue to mitigate is consumer desire vs. consumer need. With crowdsourcing research panels primarily made up of strangers rather than professionals, while they can complete tasks and problem-solve to the best of their ability they don’t have the knowledge to take advantage of each research opportunity like insight professionals do. While this sometimes leads to innovative ideas that wouldn’t have been discovered otherwise, most of the time, it takes a while for those ideas to emerge as fully-dependable insights. Allowing professionals to either moderate the discussions going on or recruit professionals to balance out the mix of participants could help enormously with this issue. Moderation is the most commonly used fix for this issue, which allows us to evaluate any ideas and insights that spark conversation. Checking to see if the response is objectively considered across the board (hard with consumers who all have their own lives to consider if this innovation is brought to life) so all ideas are treated with equal weight while discussions happen can help with this issue. While moderating is mainly used fix to this issue, there are [studies](https://symbiosisonlinepublishing.com/computer-science-technology/computerscience-information-technology01.php) to suggest that experimentation of using professionals as participants could benefit crowdsourced projects even if they do need more research into that particular topic. Regular moderation can also be very useful to help keep participants on track with discussions; derailments are a waste of time and resources in research, but is a common occurrence, especially in collaborative research tasks. With crowdsourced research communities, constant moderation while they’re working on tasks or chatting amongst each other is a mammoth unenviable task, but will be worth the work put in when the innovative ideas start flowing under the watchful eye of insight professionals in both in and out of research tasks. One thing you do need to be careful of with moderation, is not to stifle any creativity within the discussions taking place. With too rigid structures in place, it's hard for natural conversations to take place, and thus natural innovative insights to emerge. But even if crowdsourced research does generate some innovative ideas, it’s commonly known that you can’t please everyone - a sentiment that people-pleasers would happily dispute, if it didn’t mean they’d be disagreeing with you! However, it’s a fact that we encounter on a daily basis as people and as insight professionals, with participant discussions rarely 100% agreeing with each other and the data reflecting that. It’s only natural that we have conflicting opinions, but that makes it hard for us to innovate effectively when consumers change their mind, or the crowdsourced panel evolves with new participants disagreeing with those that have come before them, thus muddying the water and making those valuable insights that are generated hard to see clearly. Working with the majority to produce valuable insights works most of the time, but the need for continuous agile testing is strong in this case, and will help us decide if an innovative insight is worth the time to pursue. The last issue to discuss here, is the issue of intellectual property and data protection. If these innovative ideas, designs, products and services are created with the input of consumers, who then is entitled to the results? These crowds are not governed by the laws and contract of employment, they are operating freely on behalf of themselves rather than the company benefitting from this research. Another issue with intellectual property, is that how do we know the ideas being put forwards are original, and not stolen from another platform and company trying to achieve the same thing? | ![Tweet from FlexMR](https://www.flexmr.net/images/webpage-images/45-tweet-this-from-flexmr.png) | ***Tweet This*** | | --- | --- | | [With forethought, planning, and ingenious examples to follow, there are effective ways to mitigate the issues with crowdsourcing so that participant creativity is not stifled and innovation can still occur!](https://ctt.ac/fLJmO) | | With some forethought and extra planning, there are [a few ways](https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0007681316301240) that scientists and researchers are dealing with this issue: the first is crafting the terms and conditions to reflect the needs of the organisation, and help them gain some semblance of control over the content consumers produce while also acknowledging their contribution through fair recognition (it has been argued in [this study](https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0007681316301240) that “participants who submit content do so with the expectation that their work may be used by the soliciting organization”; the second is through legal contract, acquiring the rights to the participants’ intellectual property, or at the very least, acquiring a license to the content. ### The Complex Relationship When crowdsourcing innovation, there are a number of unique challenges insight professionals must overcome, or at least be aware of when entering into this complex relationship. It’s a lot of work, but there are a myriad of benefits to it when implemented in the right way; taking a look at success stories like Apple, Lego, and Dell, allow us to understand, firstly how it can be achieved on a long-term basis, and the impacts on the organisations who utilise this tricky methodology.  [![New call-to-action](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/1682149/a07b9b9f-fee9-447c-a050-1e3fa9d77f53.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/1682149/a07b9b9f-fee9-447c-a050-1e3fa9d77f53) #### About FlexMR We are The Insights Empowerment Company. We help research, product and marketing teams drive informed decisions with efficient, scalable & impactful insight. #### About Emily James As a professional copywriter, Emily brings our global vision to life through a broad range of industry-leading content. #### Stay up to date ## You might also like... ![Blog Featured Image Header](https://blog.flexmr.net/hubfs/Marketing_Files/Blogs/Headers/retaining_human_touch_customer_salience_cx_ai.png) ### [Retaining a Human Touch with Custom...](https://blog.flexmr.net/customer-salience-cx-ai) In recent years, companies have embraced artificial intelligence (AI) at pace, swept up in a technological momentum that promises efficiency and cost savings. However, in their rush to pursue quickly ... [Continue reading](https://blog.flexmr.net/customer-salience-cx-ai) 5 MIN READ ![Blog Featured Image Header](https://blog.flexmr.net/hubfs/Marketing_Files/Blogs/Headers/casual_conversation_iosetta_santini.png) ### [A Casual Conversation... with Ioset...](https://blog.flexmr.net/casual-conversation-iosetta-santini) Most research projects still currently end with a powerpoint report and a debrief. This has become deeply entrenched as the industry standard, and it is what stakeholders have come to expect when they... [Continue reading](https://blog.flexmr.net/casual-conversation-iosetta-santini) 4 MIN READ ![Blog Featured Image Header](https://blog.flexmr.net/hubfs/Marketing_Files/Blogs/Headers/synthetic_data_richer_market_insights.png) ### [Synthetic Data: The Key to Richer M...](https://blog.flexmr.net/synthetic-data-richer-market-insights) In the dynamic world of market research, the need for robust and accurate data is critical. Whilst the increased prevalence of generative AI has provided a range of benefits to market research process... [Continue reading](https://blog.flexmr.net/synthetic-data-richer-market-insights) 7 MIN READ ![](https://www.flexmr.net/skin/images/images-custom/48f118ee-cef9-42d6-b60b-5575d5ac26e3-flexmr_footer.svg) - [Home](https://www.flexmr.net/) - [Contact Us](https://www.flexmr.net/contact/) - [Privacy Policy](https://www.flexmr.net/legal/privacy/) - [Cookie Policy](https://www.flexmr.net/legal/cookies/) - [Terms of Use](https://www.flexmr.net/legal/terms-of-use/) [Follow us on Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/flexmr/) [Follow us on Twitter](https://twitter.com/_flexmr) [Follow us on LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/company/flexmr) [Follow us on YouTube](https://www.youtube.com/c/FlexmrNetOnlineResearch) [![Grit Top 50 Logo](https://www.flexmr.net/uploads/photo-gallery-include-images/34/44258f4d-7452-40d6-bb23-0e220c8ba21f.png)](https://www.greenbook.org/mr/grit/business-innovation-edition) [![ISO 27001 Alcumus](https://www.flexmr.net/uploads/photo-gallery-include-images/34/fa89f9b3-d866-43b8-8de0-4a052a9053d8.png)](https://www.alcumus.com/en-gb/certification/iso-27001/) [![Cyber Essentials Plus Logo](https://www.flexmr.net/uploads/photo-gallery-include-images/34/cba57df6-75a2-4544-9599-dcc0c2f14b79.png)](https://blog.flexmr.net/hubfs/Public_Files/Other/FlexMR_Cyber_Essentials_Certificate.pdf?__hstc=163229475.dde2c3d212762f49b059c9f62e7537a0.1624542718433.1626339489304.1626701624468.7&__hssc=163229475.2.1626701624468&__hsfp=3142549060) © FlexMR 2021. All rights reserved. ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@type" : "BlogPosting", "author" : { "@type" : "Person", "name" : "Emily James", "url" : "https://blog.flexmr.net/author/emily-james" }, "dateModified" : "2021-07-22T11:06:40.552Z", "datePublished" : "2020-09-11T16:20:43.000Z", "headline" : "The Complex Relationship Between Crowdsourcing and Innovation", "image" : [ "https://blog.flexmr.net/hubfs/The%20Complex%20Relationship%20Between%20Crowdsourcing%20and%20Innovation.png" ], "mainEntityOfPage" : { "@id" : "https://blog.flexmr.net/crowdsourcing-innovation-complex-relationship", "@type" : "WebPage" }, "publisher" : { "@type" : "Organization", "logo" : { "@type" : "ImageObject", "url" : "https://blog.flexmr.net/hubfs/Website_Files/Images/Logos/flexmr_logo_amp.png" }, "name" : "FlexMR" } } ```